Should Your Clients Take Social Security Early?

Determining the best age to claim Social Security is one of the most critical choices in retirement planning. While postponing benefits until full retirement age (FRA) or age 70 may result in higher monthly checks, claiming benefits as early as age 62 can make sense in certain circumstances. Below are key factors and three real-world examples to illustrate how different strategies are applied.

 

Key Factors to Weigh

  • Health & Life Expectancy
    Clients with medical issues or a family history of shorter lifespans may benefit by starting early, since they’ll collect payments over a longer span.

  • Spousal Coordination
    Coordinating claim ages (one spouse early, the other later) can increase a couple’s total lifetime benefits.

  • Working While Claiming
    Benefits claimed before FRA can be reduced if earnings exceed the annual limit. Make sure clients understand the earnings test.

  • Tax Impact
    Social Security can become taxable when combined with other income. Planning distributions from IRAs or part‑time work can help manage tax brackets.

  • Emergency Funding
    Unexpected health or long‑term care costs may arise. Encourage clients to have other sources of cash or insurance so they aren’t forced to rely solely on Social Security.

  • Other Retirement Assets
    Using 401(k)s, IRAs or cash reserves first can allow Social Security checks to grow at 8% per year delayed.

  • Break‑Even Analysis
    Calculate the age when cumulative early benefits match those from waiting. This “break‑even” point helps clients see which option pays off.

  • Debt Repayment
    Early benefits can be applied to high‑interest debts, improving net cash flow later on.

  • Advanced Filing Options
    Explore restricted applications, spousal or survivor claims to take full advantage of available rules.

  • Reversal Option
    Clients have up to 12 months to withdraw and repay benefits if they change their mind after claiming.


Scenario 1: Jane, Age 62—Income & Health Concerns

  • Background: Widowed corporate veteran with a recent health diagnosis

  • Challenges: Unexpected expenses, limited 401(k), wants to travel while still healthy

  • Assets: Mortgage paid off, minimal other debt

  • Decision: Claiming at 62 provides immediate, reliable income—enabling her to cover expenses now and enjoy retirement activities before health declines.


Scenario 2: Carlos, Age 62—Variable Earnings

  • Background: Professional artist with irregular gallery and teaching income

  • Goals: Fund an art retreat project, maintain stable cash flow

  • Assets: Owns studio outright, debt‑free

  • Decision: Early benefits smooth out income swings and supply capital for his passion project without tapping all his savings.


Scenario 3: Priya, Age 70—Building for the Long Haul

  • Background: Senior tech executive who saw peak earnings in later career years

  • Resources: Robust 401(k)/IRA balances, strong health, enjoys working

  • Spousal Impact: Husband is younger with lower lifetime earnings—waiting boosts his survivor benefit

  • Decision: Delaying past FRA raises her check by roughly 8% per year, producing larger lifetime and survivor benefits without creating tax stress now.

By reviewing each client’s health, income sources, tax situation, existing assets, and family dynamics, you can help them select the claim age that best aligns with their retirement goals.

Related Articles